Thursday March 23, 2017 Most Recent Posts:
Rodman Campground Rodman Campgroud, When to Visit and Why
Palatka, Florida Spring Equinox on the Florida National Trail
The pictures in this post were all taken on our kayaking trip down a section of the Ocklawaha River.
As I’ve said in recent previous posts, my reasons for coming to Rodman were to experience the Marjorie Harris Carr Cross Florida Greenway in which the campground is situated and to kayak her beloved Ocklawaha River.
The river damaging canal she worked so hard to stop was begun in 1935 during the great depression as an economic recovery program for the area. It was to cross Florida and allow shipping from the Atlantic to the Gulf and vice versa. Even then local opponents protested that the canal would impact the Florida aquifer and work was stopped a year later. It was reauthorized in 1942 as a national defense project but funding support in Washington wasn’t there. It was restarted in 1961. Opponents managed to get it halted in 1971 but not officially cancelled.
For nearly 40 years, from 1960 until her death in 1997, Marjorie Carr devoted her life to opposing the Cross Florida Barge Canal and saving the Ocklawaha River. In that time she managed to create a large enough coalition of opposition to the Canal project that by 1971 only one of the three dams requested by the Army Corps of Engineers had been built built, the Rodman Dam. Seventy four MILLION dollars was spent on the project before it was finally deauthorized in 1990 nearly 60 years after it began. I’m not sure whether this figure covers the outsized very tall bridges built all along the river in what became the Cross Florida Greenway.
The project was ultimately stopped but not before the Ocklawaha was dramatically changed by the dam, two sections of the canal, two locks (one abandonded when the canal was not funded that far) and the artificial reservoir referred to by its defenders as “Lake Ocklawaha” and by others as Rodman Reservoir.
The reservoir is filled with dead trees making boating quite difficult. No water skiing happening here. Dead trees are all around the shores as well.
Marjorie Carr’s fondest wish was the total restoration of the river. The Florida Defenders of the Environment, begun by Carr in 1969, continues to push for restoration of a free-flowing Ocklawaha and breaching the dam which the National Audubon Society described as “the only dam in the nation without even an alleged purpose”.
The same 2012 article quoted 19th Century poet Sidney Lanier who described the Ocklawaha as “the sweetest water-lane in the world”. FDE has an excellent article by its president on why the river should be restored. A Gainesville Sun newspaper article from December of 2015 gives the arguments from both sides. I hope to read some day soon that the river has been freed but I’m not optimistic after reading in a Florida Times Union of Jacksonville newspaper article article from October 14, 2000 stated that “this past July state officials announced a plan to tear down the dam and restore the Ocklawaha River. No time table has yet been set for its removal”. That was fifteen years ago. Nothing has yet been done.
Though restoration of the river is still an issue, over 25 years after the project was haulted, money and politics continue to make progress impossible. What else is new?
One of the saddest things I read was from a 1997 report on manatee injury and death due to the remaining Buckman Lock.. Fifteen deaths were reported from 1974 to 1996 as manatee attempted to come up the Ocklawaha from the St. Johns river looking for submerged acquatic vegetations, quiet backwaters and warm water refuge sites. The Ocklawaha has 20 springs submerged due to the dam and reservoir. The manatee were crushed or injured in the lock.. I don’t think I want to know how many have died in the past 20 years but surely as many or more.
Leslie Poole, a professor of Environmental Studies at Rollins College wrote “It is a grim and disheartening sight — a dam in north Florida that blocks the flow of the Ocklawaha River, once a jungle-like, twisting stream that inspired artists and poets. Today the Kirkpatrick (Rodman) Dam is not only an ugly hulk of concrete that hinders natural river flow and the passage of endangered species, but it is also a reminder (and remainder) of a boondoggle project that inflamed grass-roots opposition and galvanized Florida’s environmental movement.” (Kirkpatrick is the Rodman dam renamed after its strongest proponent. Both names continue to be used.)
Poole further argues that the “dam — intact along with its abutting reservoir that has been aptly described as an “aging, festering impoundment” — remains. It prevents the migration of 20 fish species, including striped bass and American shad that once left the Atlantic Ocean to spawn in the river’s upper reaches. Today that lock and dam system costs an estimated $1 million a year to maintain, and another $2 million may be needed for repairs. Damage to wildlife and a once-abundant riverine ecosystem is incalculable. Restoration might cost $20 million — less than the last 48 years’ worth of maintenance costs.”
After kayaking this river and doing this research I just can’t believe that having a bass tournament in this particular lake (reservoir) and its economic benefits to the community can possibly be worth the environmental and economic costs. This area is covered with lakes and a beautiful natural river with 20 springs and tributaries like Silver Spring would surely bring plenty of eco-tourism dollars to Putnam County.
I found it very interesting as I was doing research on this whole question that most of the things on line if you google Rodman Dam, Ocklawaha River or Cross Florida Barge canal, do not even mention Marjorie Carr nor does the informational brochure we were given at the park on the Cross Florida Greenway which was named for Marjorie Carr in 1991 when the impounded 110 miles long, one mile wide and 93, 228 acres acquired for the canal was turned over to the state for “conservation and recreation”. There is nothing mentioned about her in this brochure. Amazing! There is also nothing about her role in the Wikipedia articles either unless you directly google her name.
We have found there continue to be hard feelings on this issue in this area. One couple I talked to after our kayak referred angrily to “that Carr woman and her people who want to get rid of the reservoir where we catch a lot of fish. The area won’t never recover in my lifetime”. Marjorie Harris Carr died in 1997 but she’s still “that Carr woman”.
It’s time to honor her work and restore the Ocklawaha. There will be even more fish in the restored, free running natural river. Time to undo a big mistake.
I really hope at some future stay at Silver Springs State Park we can paddle the Silver River down to where it flows into the Ocklawaha and on to Gores Landing or beyond. I’d love to spend more time just watching the Great Egrets and others as they go about their lives.
I did spend quite a bit of time watching these four or five egrets as the river pushed me north toward the St. Johns. Each time I got near them they of course flew off in front of me rather than behind until about the fifth time when they went down a little tributary where I could see them hanging out together as I floated past.
One of the highlights of this day was watching a Swallow-tailed kite circling above.
At one point, he disappeared and then returned with something. I can’t quite make out what it is in this picture but it is either dinner or nesting materials but I’m not sure they nest here.
One real joy on the Ocklawaha is its slow speed which allows me to spend time watching the birds rather than zipping by them or having to paddle constantly to keep from heading backwards.
It isn’t often that I can watch a kingfisher.
At this point it was time for a stop at a nice turn around. The bottom of the river here is covered with what I assume are Fresh Water Mussel shells.
Fresher ones seem to have a mother of pearl lining.
There were numerous osprey along the river. At this spot at least 3 or 4 of them were calling over head but the only one I could see was above this nest.
I saw many many little birds flitting back and forth along the banks, in the trees and crossing the river. The only one I could get a decent shot of was this Phoebe. Thanks Eric & Laurel.
The only structure we saw on the river was this abandonded dock. SO nice to kayak a totally natural river, to see and hear almost only the sounds of nature.
The Great Blue Heron is all dressed up in his fancy outfit with his blue breeding lore (bare skin between his eyes and bill).
David missed seeing this Anhinga drying her wings even though he was right in front of her. He said he was looking at a kingfisher on the end of the same tree. Not sure how you can miss a bird this big but he scared her off as he paddled by.
In order to get to the original Ocklawaha River in this area you have to cross a piece of the canal so one the way back I take this picture of the infamous dam and the straight as an arrow canal. The dam is on my left, the canal on my right as I paddle across. The reservoir is behind the dam. None of these is nearly as interesting as the beautiful river. Hope to hear some day soon that the dam, canal and reservoir are history and the river is running free.
Our next stop will be Wekiwa Springs as we approach the end this year’s Florida tour. I think we may have over stayed this year as the weather people are predicting temperatures in the 90’s for next week. WHEW – that’s not going to bring a smile to my face. Guess there will be a lot of swimming in the spring. Things could be worse.